Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

The practice of martial arts, research, interpretation and modern practice. Ancient to c.1900. Worldwide, Eastern and Western.
Open to public view.

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Lidsman » 04 Feb 2017 09:26

So where is mr Easton, I ask myself, we need your wisdom good sir.
Ulf Ulfson Lidsman
----)--------------------
"Those who beat their swords into plowshares usually end up plowing for those who don't."
Benjamin Franklin
Lidsman
Sergeant
 
Posts: 136
Joined: 01 Jan 2016 12:55
Location: Upland, Sweden

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Jakob von Schubert » 04 Feb 2017 12:02

Lidsman wrote:So where is mr Easton, I ask myself, we need your wisdom good sir.

Nah, I can't blame him. This topic has been probably discussed too many times.
And maybe, well, some of my questions may have been too naive and nosey.
User avatar
Jakob von Schubert
Private
 
Posts: 16
Joined: 20 Jan 2017 22:07
Location: Hamburg-St. Pauli, Germany

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby swordflasher » 04 Feb 2017 14:01

Maybe an antique Dutch klewang, if you prefer a shorter more cutlassy alternative to the Infantry officers sword (backsword).
There is a world elsewhere
User avatar
swordflasher
Field Marshal
 
Posts: 9095
Joined: 14 Mar 2006 21:56
Location: Stepping back from the edge

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Lidsman » 04 Feb 2017 15:19

swordflasher wrote:Maybe an antique Dutch klewang, if you prefer a shorter more cutlassy alternative to the Infantry officers sword (backsword).


The US 1917 cutlass is aparently model after the klewang. I prefer the british cutlass.
Ulf Ulfson Lidsman
----)--------------------
"Those who beat their swords into plowshares usually end up plowing for those who don't."
Benjamin Franklin
Lidsman
Sergeant
 
Posts: 136
Joined: 01 Jan 2016 12:55
Location: Upland, Sweden

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby swordflasher » 05 Feb 2017 01:27

Can't say I like the look or handling of British cutlasses myself, but it's a matter of taste I suppose. There used to be an antique weapons shop near the Wallace with a bin full of them.

Mind you I've not handled an antique klewang, I just think they look cool. How do the US ones handle?
There is a world elsewhere
User avatar
swordflasher
Field Marshal
 
Posts: 9095
Joined: 14 Mar 2006 21:56
Location: Stepping back from the edge

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Jakob von Schubert » 05 Feb 2017 01:36

swordflasher wrote:Maybe an antique Dutch klewang, if you prefer a shorter more cutlassy alternative to the Infantry officers sword (backsword).

The klewang looks pretty top-heavy, again.
What are you guys' thoughts about that anyway: you like the POB near the hilt, or do you not mind your swords being top-heavy?
User avatar
Jakob von Schubert
Private
 
Posts: 16
Joined: 20 Jan 2017 22:07
Location: Hamburg-St. Pauli, Germany

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Lidsman » 05 Feb 2017 09:02

swordflasher wrote:Can't say I like the look or handling of British cutlasses myself, but it's a matter of taste I suppose. There used to be an antique weapons shop near the Wallace with a bin full of them.

Mind you I've not handled an antique klewang, I just think they look cool. How do the US ones handle?


I have not handle any of the I just go by the looks :D
Ulf Ulfson Lidsman
----)--------------------
"Those who beat their swords into plowshares usually end up plowing for those who don't."
Benjamin Franklin
Lidsman
Sergeant
 
Posts: 136
Joined: 01 Jan 2016 12:55
Location: Upland, Sweden

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Lidsman » 05 Feb 2017 09:03

Jakob von Schubert wrote:
swordflasher wrote:Maybe an antique Dutch klewang, if you prefer a shorter more cutlassy alternative to the Infantry officers sword (backsword).

The klewang looks pretty top-heavy, again.
What are you guys' thoughts about that anyway: you like the POB near the hilt, or do you not mind your swords being top-heavy?


Its a matter of context :lol:
Ulf Ulfson Lidsman
----)--------------------
"Those who beat their swords into plowshares usually end up plowing for those who don't."
Benjamin Franklin
Lidsman
Sergeant
 
Posts: 136
Joined: 01 Jan 2016 12:55
Location: Upland, Sweden

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Jakob von Schubert » 05 Feb 2017 13:05

Lidsman wrote:Its a matter of context :lol:

Oi, but what possible context could ask for a top-heavy sword? The job of a medieval decapitater?
In all other contexts it seems to me that it's better to be able to move the top-part, if not the point, of a sword rather precisely.
And still, there are swords like that klewang. Anyone of you has had any satisfying experiences with top-heavy swords?
User avatar
Jakob von Schubert
Private
 
Posts: 16
Joined: 20 Jan 2017 22:07
Location: Hamburg-St. Pauli, Germany

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Lidsman » 05 Feb 2017 13:12

Jakob von Schubert wrote:
Lidsman wrote:Its a matter of context :lol:

Oi, but what possible context could ask for a top-heavy sword?


If you have a shield a top-heavy weapon can't be wrong against unarmored opponents or those wearing mail. Or am I mistaken?
Ulf Ulfson Lidsman
----)--------------------
"Those who beat their swords into plowshares usually end up plowing for those who don't."
Benjamin Franklin
Lidsman
Sergeant
 
Posts: 136
Joined: 01 Jan 2016 12:55
Location: Upland, Sweden

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Jakob von Schubert » 05 Feb 2017 15:00

Lidsman wrote:If you have a shield a top-heavy weapon can't be wrong against unarmored opponents or those wearing mail. Or am I mistaken?

That's the question to be answered by the veterans around here, I guess.
User avatar
Jakob von Schubert
Private
 
Posts: 16
Joined: 20 Jan 2017 22:07
Location: Hamburg-St. Pauli, Germany

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Jakob von Schubert » 05 Feb 2017 15:08

However, let me give this discussion a new direction: as of the end of 2016, the beginning of 2017, what is the best standard manufacture these days? I'm not talking about the German masters who forge your individual sword for 1600€, but about the manufacture that'd build you a slightly customized standard.
User avatar
Jakob von Schubert
Private
 
Posts: 16
Joined: 20 Jan 2017 22:07
Location: Hamburg-St. Pauli, Germany

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Lidsman » 05 Feb 2017 16:03

Jakob von Schubert wrote:However, let me give this discussion a new direction: as of the end of 2016, the beginning of 2017, what is the best standard manufacture these days? I'm not talking about the German masters who forge your individual sword for 1600€, but about the manufacture that'd build you a slightly customized standard.


For your original price rag of about €600? I would say Marco Danelli, Paul Binns and probably a bunch of East-European smiths. For a little bit more I would say Albion.

BUT, the best buy would be an original cutlass/sabre/broadsword/hanger and for €600 you get a lot. An original would allways be better than a copy of the same price.
Ulf Ulfson Lidsman
----)--------------------
"Those who beat their swords into plowshares usually end up plowing for those who don't."
Benjamin Franklin
Lidsman
Sergeant
 
Posts: 136
Joined: 01 Jan 2016 12:55
Location: Upland, Sweden

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Jakob von Schubert » 05 Feb 2017 21:19

Lidsman wrote:BUT, the best buy would be an original cutlass/sabre/broadsword/hanger and for €600 you get a lot.


Hm. What I found was this page, which puts a 1 or 2 in front or even a 0 at the end of my price range.
http://www.albanarms.com/index.php?page ... ean-swords
User avatar
Jakob von Schubert
Private
 
Posts: 16
Joined: 20 Jan 2017 22:07
Location: Hamburg-St. Pauli, Germany

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Lidsman » 05 Feb 2017 21:38

Jakob von Schubert wrote:
Lidsman wrote:BUT, the best buy would be an original cutlass/sabre/broadsword/hanger and for €600 you get a lot.


Hm. What I found was this page, which puts a 1 or 2 in front or even a 0 at the end of my price range.
http://www.albanarms.com/index.php?page ... ean-swords


Indeed they do. Well, maybe its only a cutlass or a sabre you can get then but there are a lit of really good sabres out there.
Ulf Ulfson Lidsman
----)--------------------
"Those who beat their swords into plowshares usually end up plowing for those who don't."
Benjamin Franklin
Lidsman
Sergeant
 
Posts: 136
Joined: 01 Jan 2016 12:55
Location: Upland, Sweden

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby swordflasher » 05 Feb 2017 21:42

Search for an antique infantry officers sword [not sabre]. They are mostly straight, and so an affordable backsword.

Such as the one at the beginning of Matt's video here. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5N4eKvVhZvQ


Matt's advice about where to buy antique swords https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iphVHZbUm2w
There is a world elsewhere
User avatar
swordflasher
Field Marshal
 
Posts: 9095
Joined: 14 Mar 2006 21:56
Location: Stepping back from the edge

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Lidsman » 06 Feb 2017 09:19

Ulf Ulfson Lidsman
----)--------------------
"Those who beat their swords into plowshares usually end up plowing for those who don't."
Benjamin Franklin
Lidsman
Sergeant
 
Posts: 136
Joined: 01 Jan 2016 12:55
Location: Upland, Sweden

Re: Which and by whom is your best functional sword in 2017?

Postby Jakob von Schubert » 06 Feb 2017 20:16

Yeah, these are quite some examples to consider.
User avatar
Jakob von Schubert
Private
 
Posts: 16
Joined: 20 Jan 2017 22:07
Location: Hamburg-St. Pauli, Germany

Previous

Return to Historical Martial Arts

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests

cron